Best Canned Pizza Sauce

If you’re a fan of pizza, you know that the sauce can make or break the pizza. Finding the best-canned pizza sauce can be a daunting task, as there are so many brands and varieties available in the market. That’s why I’ve taken it upon myself to find the best-canned pizza sauce on the market. 

I’ve tried and tested the top-rated options. So all you have to do is get one of these pizza sauces at home to make the yummiest pizza you will ever have. From the tangy tomato to the chilly hot, I have got everything for you under one roof.

Contadina Pizza Sauce – Our Top Choice

Contadina Canned Pizza Sauce, 12 Pack, 15 oz Can
  • RICH TASTE: Add flavor to mouth-watering pizza with this creamy and hearty pizza sauce, cooked down using whole tomatoes that are made from the finest ingredients and picked at the peak of freshness
  • NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Packed with a flavor of finest Roma tomatoes, the sauce is seasoned to perfection and contains natural sea salt
  • NO PRESERVATIVES: Non-GMO, and non-BPA, this tomato paste is perfect for elevating any meal
  • EASY STORAGE: This canned tomato paste is carefully sealed and packaged to keep in its freshness. The paste is simple to store in a pantry for easy use when making delicious pizzas
  • PREMIUM QUALITY: Contadina has been the standard bearer of passion and commitment ever since its inception, nearly a 100 years ago in 1918. We provide quality by using fresh, vine-ripened Roma tomatoes that are grown and packed with care

Product Highlights

Contadina Pizza Sauce is a super delicious and flavorful sauce made with vine-ripened tomatoes blended with herbs and spices to give it a classic Italian flavor. It’s a versatile sauce that can be used on any type of pizza, and it’s also great for dipping breadsticks or as a base for pasta dishes.


  • Made with vine-ripened tomatoes
  • Made from 100% natural ingredients, with no artificial preservatives or flavors
  • Easy to spread and use
  • Comes in a convenient resealable can 

What I Like About Contadina Pizza Sauce

Personally, I’m a big fan of this sauce. I mean, who doesn’t love a rich and tangy tomato flavor on their pizza? One thing I really appreciate about Contadina is that it’s made without any artificial preservatives or flavors. It feels good to know that I’m using a product with real ingredients.

When it comes to using the sauce, it’s a breeze to spread on pizza dough. I’ve used it as a base for all kinds of toppings, and it always turns out delicious. And can we talk about the resealable can for a second? It’s a total game-changer for those of us who like to save the leftover sauce for later use.

What I Don’t Like About Contadina Pizza Sauce

Now, as much as I love Contadina Pizza Sauce, there are a couple of things that I think could be improved. For one, the sauce is not on the sweeter side, which might not be everyone’s cup of tea. And for some people, the sauce can be a bit thin, which can lead to a soggy crust if you use too much.

Pros & Cons:

Made with vine-ripened tomatoesThe sauce is not on the sweeter side.
Contains no artificial preservatives, making it a healthier option.Some people may find it more expensive compared to other tomato-based products.
Contains no added sugar, making it a good choice for those who are watching their sugar intakeSome people may find the consistency too thick or chunky

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Product Highlights

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a premium quality tomato sauce that’s perfect for pizza lovers! This sauce is made from all-natural ingredients and has a rich, flavorful taste that will make your pizza taste like it’s straight from a pizzeria. It’s a favorite among pizza lovers for its delicious taste and convenience.


  • Made with all-natural ingredients
  • Rich and authentic flavor
  • Available in convenient 15 oz cans
  • Gluten-free and low in calories

What I Like About Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

There are many things to love about Don Pepino Pizza Sauce. First and foremost, its flavor is outstanding. It has the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity, with just the right amount of herbs and spices to make it taste like it’s been simmering on the stove all day. 

I also appreciate that it’s gluten-free and doesn’t contain any preservatives. And, of course, the fact that it comes in a can means it’s easy to store and use whenever you’re in the mood for pizza.

What I Don’t Like About Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

The only downside to Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is that it can be a bit pricey compared to other pizza sauces on the market. However, I think the quality and flavor are well worth the extra cost.

Pros and Cons

Made with fresh vine-ripened tomatoes, which give the sauce a rich and authentic taste. It may not be suitable for individuals who prefer a spicier or more savory taste.
Thick and smooth consistency, making it easy to spread on pizza crusts.Contains added sugar, which may not be suitable for individuals on a low-sugar diet.

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese

Product Highlights

Chef Boyardee is a well-known brand that produces affordable and convenient canned meals, including canned pizza sauce. Their pizza sauce is made with vine-ripened tomatoes, cheddar cheese, and a blend of spices, providing a rich and hearty flavor.  Their pizza sauce can be used as a base for homemade pizzas or as a dipping sauce for breadsticks and other snacks.


  • 15 oz can
  • No artificial preservatives
  • Ready to use sauce 
  • Smooth texture

What I Like About Chef Boyardee

One of the best things about Chef Boyardee’s pizza sauce is its affordability and convenience. The sauce is ready to use straight out of the can, making it an excellent option for a quick and easy homemade pizza night. It also has a rich flavor that is sure to satisfy any pizza lover.

What I Don’t Like About Chef Boyardee

One drawback of Chef Boyardee’s pizza sauce is that it can be pretty salty. If you’re watching your sodium intake, this might not be the best option for you. Additionally, you might find a slightly artificial taste, which might not be to everyone’s liking.

An affordable option for making homemade pizzas.Contains preservatives and artificial flavors, which may not be suitable for individuals looking for a healthier option.
Has a mildly sweet and salty taste that most people enjoy.Thin consistency, making it difficult to spread on pizza crusts.
Ready to use, so no additional preparation is necessary, and it is available in most grocery stores.It may contain high amounts of sodium, which may not be suitable for individuals with high blood pressure or other health conditions.

What to Look for When Buying Canned Pizza Sauce?

1. Flavor and Taste

When it comes to canned pizza sauce, the flavor and taste are undoubtedly the most crucial factors to consider. A good sauce should be rich in tomato flavor, slightly tangy, and not too sweet. It should also have the right balance of herbs and spices, such as basil, oregano, and garlic, to enhance the flavor profile.

2. Texture and Consistency

The texture and consistency of canned pizza sauce can also impact the final result. A good sauce should be smooth, without any lumps or chunks, and should be spread evenly over the pizza base. It should also be thick enough to prevent the crust from getting soggy but not too thick that it overpowers the other ingredients.

3. Ingredients

The ingredients used in canned pizza sauce can also make a significant difference in its quality. Look for sauces made with high-quality ingredients, such as vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh herbs, and spices, without any artificial preservatives or additives.

What to Look For When Buying Canned Pizza Sauce

When it comes to buying pizza sauce, there are a few important aspects to consider. 


Of course, the most important aspect of any pizza sauce is its flavor. Look for a sauce that has a balance of sweetness and acidity, with a rich tomato flavor. 


Another important aspect is the consistency of the sauce. You don’t want a sauce that’s too runny or too thick. A good canned pizza sauce should be thick enough to spread evenly over the pizza crust but not so thick that it’s difficult to work with. 

Brand Reputation

When it comes to food products, it’s always a good idea to go with a reputable brand. Look for brands that have a long history of producing quality products.


Price is always a consideration when it comes to buying food products. Canned pizza sauce is generally not too expensive, but there can be variations in price between different brands.



After trying out a bunch of different canned pizza sauces, I gotta say that my top pick is definitely Contadina. 

This sauce is seriously delicious – it’s got a super authentic tomato flavor, with just the right amount of spices and herbs to really make your taste buds dance. Plus, the texture is just perfect – it’s nice and smooth, so it spreads over your pizza base like a dream. 

Contadina only uses high-quality, natural ingredients. No yucky preservatives or additives here at all! So, if you’re in the market for a seriously tasty pizza sauce, I highly recommend checking out Contadina. You can grab a can for yourself right here!


Q: Is canned pizza sauce healthy? 

A: It depends on the brand and the ingredients used. Look for sauces made with high-quality ingredients, without any artificial preservatives or additives, and in moderation.

Q: Can you freeze canned pizza sauce?

A: Yes, you can freeze canned pizza sauce for up to three months. Make sure to store it in an airtight container and thaw it before using it.

Q: Are these canned pizza sauces gluten-free?

A: Contadina and Don Pepino canned pizza sauces are gluten-free. Chef Boyardee’s pizza sauce contains wheat flour and is not gluten-free.

Q: Should I look for a low-sodium option when choosing a canned pizza sauce?

A: It is recommended to look for a low-sodium option when choosing a canned pizza sauce, as excessive sodium can lead to health issues.

Q: Is canned pizza sauce better than homemade?

A: It depends on individual tastes and preferences. Canned pizza sauce is convenient and has a longer shelf life, while homemade sauce allows for more customization and freshness.

Q: How long does canned pizza sauce last?

A: Canned pizza sauce can last for up to two years if unopened and stored in a cool, dry place.