As pizza enthusiasts and experts in testing different kinds of pizza products, we have made and tasted the best Amazon Fresh pizza you can order online. We’ve also created a list of the best among them. Aside from the list, we will provide you with a detailed review of each product.
Here are our top picks:
- Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
- DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
- Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
1) Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio – Our Top Pick
Highlights of Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
This dish is made with 100% natural mozzarella provolone and parmesan cheese. The crust is crispy and crunchy, not too thin but not too thick either. The natural tomato sauce combined with the cheese trio makes this pizza taste so great. With simple and high-quality ingredients, this pizza doesn’t taste like frozen pizza.
Features of Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
With only 320 calories per serving, this guilty pleasure will not make you regret a single bite. It cost only $5.29, and the 17.82 oz size is a perfect dinner for two people. It is one of the products with the best quality-to-price ratio you can find. Here are the main characteristics:
- Main Ingredients – Cheese, wheat flour, milk, tomato paste, soybean oil, yeast, onion powder,
- Preparation is easy and fast, only 16-20 minutes in an oven on 400F,
- Low-cost pizza that tastes like it’s from a restaurant,
- There is no need to defrost before baking.
What We Like About Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
The main thing we like about this pizza is the simplicity of the ingredients. There is no risk of getting meat on top of it or salami that can only ruin the taste of pizza. If you are a true pizza lover, you will find this product (as we have) great when eaten by itself or even better – when you add some of your favorite pizza toppings. You can garnish this pizza with some fresh basil, prosciutto, or the best ham for pizza on top of it and have the most amazing dish ever. Once it is baked, the cheese will melt to perfection.
What We Don’t Like about Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
Like in any product there are things that lack and can be improved. Here are some pros and cons of this pizza.
| Pros | Cons |
| Low price | It contains soy |
| Good serving size | When it’s cold it becomes too hard to eat |
| Good quality cheese | Not good when reheated |
| Tasty tomato sauce |
2) DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
Highlights of DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
Second on our list is DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza. It belongs to the supreme frozen pizza collection. This pizza, with hand-tossed dough with Italian sausage, pepperoni, real cheese, and green and red bell peppers, is a perfect combination of Italian and American-style dishes. A soft and airy crust that is crispy from the outside is perfect for two people. It cost only $7.50 for 21.3 oz.
Features of DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
Here are the main features of DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza:
- Frozen dish with real cheese, fresh peppers, and caramelized onions
- Main ingredients – Wheat flour, cooked Italian sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, tomato paste, peppers onion, soybean oil or corn oil, yeast, salt, and sugar.
What We Like About Digiorno Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
The main thing we like about this pizza is its dough – it really feels like it is made from good quality flour and other ingredients. The crust is soft and airy, but it is not too thick to make you feel like eating bread. The combination of peppers, caramelized onion, and Italian sausage is great. And even though it has pepperoni on it (not our personal favorite,) it still doesn’t overpower the flavor of other ingredients.
What We Don’t Like about DIGIORNO Hand-Tossed Style Pizza
Even though this pizza tastes great, there are some downsides to it. Here are some of them.
| Pros | Cons |
| Amazing crust | It can get soggy if not baked properly |
| Fresh ingredients | It contains soy |
| Good size | |
| Low-cost price |
3) Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
Highlights of Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
For all those who like good quality cheese on thin crust, Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese pizza is a winner. It cost only $3.59, but the serving size is smaller than our other picks – 13.8 oz. This is an excellent product to keep in your freezer to make a quick dinner for one. Although the crust is fine, the sauce may feel like it is not made from natural ingredients.
Features of Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
- It is low-cost pizza for one person
- Thin and crispy crust topped with tasty cheese
- Main ingredients are mozzarella, wheat and malted barley flour, tomato paste, parmesan cheese, soy lecithin, dry garlic, and yeast.
What We Like About Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
The main thing we like is the thin crust and simplicity of the ingredients, and like with our top pick, this pizza can be easily enriched with some products you have at home. Also, the serving size is perfect for one person meaning there will be no leftovers or eating too much of it.
What We Don’t Like About Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza
Here are the main pros and cons of Jack’s Original Thin Crust Cheese Frozen Pizza.
| Pros | Cons |
| Low-cost | Small size for family |
| Thin crust | Not good when reheated |
| Tasty cheese | Crust may be too hard to eat |
| Sauce doesn’t taste natural |
What to Look for When Buying Pizza?
Ingredients
The main thing to look for is the ingredients. Aside from fine-printed ingredients you will see on the package, such as potassium or other harmful stuff, you need to think about the main ingredients. It is frozen pizza, so don’t buy any product that has fresh meat on it. In all likelihood, this will taste terrible.
What Kind of Crust Do You Like?
Thin or thick crust is up to your personal taste. But usually, the frozen thick crust can turn out to be soggy.
Final Verdict – the Best Amazon Fresh Pizza Is Red Baron Pizza, Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio
If we look at the US pizza menu with the accent on frozen pizzas available on Amazon Fresh, we must conclude that Red Baron Pizza is the best. With this pizza, you don’t have to wonder how much is a Brick Pizza Oven because you get to have this experience just a click away. The crust is crispy and does taste like it just came out of the brick oven. The tomato paste tasted natural, like it was a real marinara sauce. For a frozen pizza option, there is no doubt this is the best choice. Just keep in mind this is frozen pizza, and once it is baked, it should be eaten right away.
FAQ
Are These Mini Pizzas?
No, this pizza is not mini. They are 17.82 oz, excellent for two people.
Are There Other Types of Red Baron Pizzas?
Red Baron Pizzas have Classic Four Cheese Pizza, Classic Pepperoni Pizza, Red Baron Pizza, and Thin & Crispy Pepperoni pizzas available on Amazon Fresh.