How Long Is Cheese Pizza Good For?

Have you had an opportunity to eat the most delicious cheese pizza you’ve ordered at a pizza store? The melting cheese, crispy crust, and incredible ingredients make it hard not to save some pieces for later. But how long is a cheese pizza good for, and how can you store it?

A cheese pizza goes bad overnight if you don’t make sure to store it correctly. At room temperature, it is good for two hours while in the fridge for up to four days. But, if you put it in a plastic container and then in the freezer, it won’t spoil for up to two months.

Cheese pizza on a plate

How Long Is a Cheese Pizza Good For, and How Can You Store It?

The situation has happened more times than we can count. Tasty Donatos grilled cheese pizzas or mouth-watering Domino’s pizzas get delivered to your front door, and there are more pieces in the box than you can eat. What should you do? You cannot simply throw the rest of the box away.

The good news is that you can keep the leftover pieces and store them.  However, if you plan to put the pieces back in the box and leave them on the dining room table, you’ll find that the meal gets spoiled after two to three hours.

In case you plan on eating the dish the next day, you can just place a couple of cheese pizza pieces on a plate and put the plate in the fridge. Pizzas stored in this way won’t get spoiled for four days.

But, if you want to store the slices for as long as possible, then put them in the freezers. It will be safe to reheat them in a pizza oven and eat them for up to two to three months.

Pizza on a wooden board

What Are the Steps for Storing Pizzas in a Freezer?

You don’t want to make any mistakes when preparing Pizzas from Pizza Hut, Domino’s, or Papa John’s for the freezer since freezer burns can spoil the dish. Here are the steps to ensure that you can safely eat the slices after a month or two.

Step 1Let the pizzas cool down
Step 2Wrap all the slices with a plastic wrap
Step 3Put the wrapped slices in an airtight container or a zip-top reusable bag.
Step 4Label the container with the date when the dish was prepared.
Step 5Put the pizzas in the freezer until you want to reheat them and eat them.

What Are the Signs of a Spoiled Pizza?

Have you often asked yourself a truly mind-boggling question – Is this slice of pizza still good, or do I need to throw it away immediately? It’s safe to say that you’ve always opted for the first option and maybe regretted your decision later on. How can you know not to make this mistake again? We can help you. Here are the signs that you shouldn’t consume leftover cheese pizza:

  • If you notice mold on the crust – Has the slice changed color? The mold is a sure sign you shouldn’t consume it since it will most likely make you sick.
  • There is a foul smell – A stale dish is a cause for concern. If you can notice a rotten and unpleasant smell, the slice has most likely gone bad.
  • Unpleasant taste – Don’t pressure yourself into eating a pizza if it tastes sour or even too sweet.
  • The ingredients have become gooey – If you notice that the cheese has become slimy, plus it tastes rotten and sour, don’t consume the slice.

Have You Kept Your Pizza in a Freezer? Here Is How to Reheat It Properly

How can you bring back the freshness of a Domino’s or Pizza Hut pizza that has been in your freezer for a month. It’s true that the taste will not be the same as with the piping-hot pizza fresh out of the oven, but there is a way to make it a bit more delicious and enjoyable. Follow our advice and you will be blown away how good a frozen pizza can taste.

You Can Heat It Up in an Oven

One of the easiest ways to reheat a dish is by using a traditional oven. What you should do is take the pizzas out of the freezer and keep them at room temperature for an hour or two. Then, turn up the heat of your oven to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Let the oven come warm a bit, before you place the pizzas inside. It will take about five minutes to heat one side, then flip the slices over and leave them in the oven for five minutes more. Finally, it’s ready to be served.

Joyful women looking at a slice of pizza

Another Method Includes Using a Skillet

Do you want the slices to be crispier? Then, use a pan and heat up the pizzas. Bear in mind that you shouldn’t put the slices in the pan if they are still completely frozen.

After leaving them at room temperature for a couple of hours, you can take a skillet and pour in one tablespoon of olive oil. Grill the slices until they become light brown again. Try to flip them as much as possible while grilling.

When they are done, add a bit of cheese you have in your fridge so that it melts on top of the slice. It will be a truly tasty leftover pizza for sure.

Cheese pizza on a wooden platter

A Quick and Easy Trick – Put the Slices in the Microwave

If you are not in the mood for grilling or heating up your oven, don’t worry, use a microwave instead. Separate your slices on plates made out of plastic and microwave every slice of pizza for approximately two to three minutes.

In case it doesn’t become warm, just microwave it again. Even though it won’t be crispy and brown like when reheating it in a skillet or an oven, you can always add pieces of cheese and other fresh ingredients so that the dish is more tasty.

Store Your Pizza Correctly and It Will Be Good for a Longer Period of Time

Now that you know when and how to store your cheese pizza, you won’t have to wonder whether something is still good or whether it should be thrown away. Keep your cheese pizzas in the fridge for up to five days or simply store the slices in the freezers for up to two to three months. However, don’t make the mistake of eating a slice that has been sitting all day at room temperature.